Making the Decision

My dentist says the tooth should come out: should I get a second opinion?

A second opinion is not a sign of mistrust; it is a normal step to take before a decision that cannot be undone

A tooth that has been taken out does not come back, which is why being advised to have an extraction is one of the most legitimate reasons for a second opinion. On this page we set out when a second opinion is genuinely necessary, what you should take with you, which questions you should put to the second dentist and when you should act without waiting. And because we know we are not a neutral party here either, we have also written about how to assess us.

Short answer

When you are presented with an extraction, an extensive plan or an unexpected cost, getting a second opinion is normal, and it is your right. Take your latest X-ray, your CBCT scan if you have one, the written treatment plan and a list of the medicines you take. Two dentists looking at the same image and recommending different things does not necessarily mean one of them is wrong; asking where the difference comes from gives you the real information. The one exception is an active infection: that cannot wait.

The most legitimate reason: A recommended extraction: a decision that cannot be undone
Take with you: X-ray, CBCT scan, written plan, list of medicines
The question that matters: Is there a way to keep this tooth, and at what cost?
When not to wait: Swelling, fever, a spreading infection

Medically reviewed by Bilge Ilgın, Dentist · ImplantologyLast reviewed 2026-09-06

When a second opinion is genuinely necessary

Not every recommendation calls for a second opinion. For limited procedures that can be undone, such as a filling, a scale and polish or a single root canal treatment, a second appointment is usually a waste of time. The value of a second opinion shows where the decision cannot be undone: an extraction, several teeth being taken out at once, bone surgery or a plan that covers the whole mouth. In these four cases, a second look can genuinely change the outcome.

Two dentists saying different things does not, in most cases, mean that one of them is wrong. The same X-ray can lead to two different approaches: one prioritises keeping the tooth in the mouth for as long as possible, the other prioritises preserving the remaining bone and building the plan as a whole. Both can be defended. Your job is not to work out which one is right, but to understand which reasoning fits your situation.

The rule people most often skip when getting a second opinion is this: give the second dentist the same information. A dentist without your X-ray can only guess, and that guess usually comes out more cautious, sometimes more aggressive. Take every record you have. You have the right to ask for your images; clinics are obliged to share them, and a good clinic will not make a fuss about it.

Behind a recommendation to extract there is usually one of three reasons: most of the bone holding the tooth has resorbed, the root has split along its length, or there is not enough sound tooth left to build anything on. All three can be shown on the images and during an examination. A recommendation to extract made without showing you the reason is an incomplete recommendation; asking to be shown is a perfectly normal request.

The reverse is also true, and it is talked about less: sometimes a second opinion confirms not that the tooth can be saved, but that it cannot. A tooth that has been kept going for months and treated every few months may be staying in place at the expense of the bone around it. That bone is where an implant will sit in future. So not every second opinion says 'let's save the tooth'; sometimes it says 'don't put it off', and that is a valuable answer too.

Finally, let us be open about where we stand. We are a clinic that does this work, which means we are not an impartial referee. That is why we have a rule for the second-opinion requests that come to us: if we think you are not suitable, we put that in writing, and we tell you that our protocol is not needed for a problem with a single tooth. Use the same yardstick when you assess us: a clinic that can tell you when you are not suitable for something is more trustworthy than one that tells you it can do everything.

When to get a second opinion, and when to go straight to treatment

The breakdown below separates the situations where a second opinion helps from those where it only costs you time.

The tooth can be saved

If an extraction has been recommendedThis is the one decision that cannot be undone. Ask to be shown on the image why the tooth cannot be saved; if the reason is bone loss, a vertical fracture or too little tooth left, a second opinion usually confirms the same conclusion. Even that confirmation brings peace of mind.
If you have been given a plan covering your whole mouthHaving several teeth taken out at once and a plan for full-mouth replacement teeth is a big decision. How many teeth genuinely cannot be saved, and why the plan has been drawn up on this scale, are worth discussing with a second dentist.
If a bone graft and a long wait are recommendedA graft is an item that adds to both the cost and the timeline. In plans where the anchorage can be taken from the deep bone that does not resorb, it is not needed in most cases. It makes sense to ask whether that option applies to your mouth.
If there is a big gap between the recommendation and what you expectedIf you went in about one tooth and came out with a plan for ten, you need to understand the reason for that difference. The reason may be valid, but it should not be accepted without being understood.

Saving it is unlikely to hold

If you have spreading swelling, a fever or difficulty swallowingWaiting for a second opinion here does harm. These signs show that the infection has spread into the soft tissues, and it progresses within hours. See a dentist the same day; if you are struggling to swallow, go straight to A&E.
For limited procedures that can be undoneFor a filling, a scale and polish or a single root canal treatment, a second opinion is usually a waste of time. The result can be undone, and the delay itself creates a cost.
An opinion given without the same informationAn opinion given without seeing the X-ray and the plan is not a second opinion but a guess. An examination carried out without your records does not count as a second opinion and can give you false confidence.
If you are going only to hear what you want to hearLooking for a third, fourth and fifth opinion until you hear the answer you want is not making a decision; it is putting the decision off. The months that go by in the meantime are not without cost to your bone.

How to get a second opinion the right way

Following the order below makes sure the second opinion gives you information you can genuinely compare.

1
Ask for your records
Your panoramic X-ray, your CBCT scan if you have one, any photos taken inside your mouth and the written treatment plan. These are your health records; asking for a copy is a normal request and should not be refused.
2
Write down your medicines and medical conditions
Every medicine you take, any long-term conditions and any operations you have had. Blood thinners, medicines for your bones and diabetes medicines directly affect the plan; take the list in writing rather than relying on memory.
3
Do not mention the first opinion at the start
Mention it once the examination is over. Hearing the dentist's own assessment first means the two opinions are genuinely independent. Then show them the first plan and ask what lies behind the difference.
4
Ask to be shown the reasoning on the image
Why can't this tooth be saved? How much bone is left? Where is the fracture? These are questions that can be answered by pointing to the image. If they cannot be shown, the answer is incomplete.
5
Ask about the alternatives and their trade-offs
If there is a way to keep the tooth, what is it, how many years does it buy you and what happens to the bone around it during that time? The answer should cover both what you gain and what it costs you.
6
Compare the two in writing
Put the two plans side by side: scope, duration, number of appointments, cost and what happens afterwards. Plans that are not in writing cannot be compared; any detail that is only agreed verbally shifts over time.

Options worth discussing when an extraction is recommended

What people really want to know at a second opinion is this: is there a way to keep this tooth? The points below are the headings for that conversation.

Root canal treatment, or redoing it

If the inflammation is in the nerve and the bone around the root is intact, the tooth may be able to stay. In a tooth that has already had root canal treatment, the treatment can be redone. What decides it is how sound the root is and the condition of the supporting bone.

Gum treatment

If the tooth is loose because of inflammation and the bone loss is not advanced, it may become less loose after a deep clean. If most of the bone has resorbed, this route does not save the tooth; it only prolongs things.

Keeping the tooth a while longer

In some cases the tooth can be kept in the mouth until the planned treatment. But this comes at a price: the bone around it keeps resorbing. When this option is discussed, the bone lost should be discussed as well as the time gained.

Dealing with the extraction and the gap in the same plan

If the decision to extract has been made, the real question is what will go in its place. When a gap is left, the opposing tooth in the other jaw drifts into the space, the neighbouring teeth tilt and the bone in that area resorbs. That is why the next step is planned before the extraction.

One tooth, or the whole mouth

A problem with one tooth does not need a full-mouth plan, and even though saying so is not in our interest, it is the truth. Our protocol is for patients missing many teeth; for a single gap, carrying on with your own dentist is enough.

Traps people fall into when getting a second opinion

We write about these because they have actually happened; each of them defeats the purpose of a second opinion.

Putting off the decision by collecting opinions

Asking five clinics the same question is not making a decision. During the months that go by, the bone keeps resorbing and the options narrow. Two good opinions are worth more than five superficial ones.

Looking only at the price

If two plans describe different work, comparing their prices is meaningless. Make the scope the same first: how many implants, what bridgework, whether check-ups are included. Then look at the figure.

Going without your records

An opinion given without an X-ray is a guess and can give you false confidence. A second opinion taken without your records is not a second opinion.

Looking for opinions while there is an infection

When there is swelling, a fever and difficulty swallowing, waiting does harm. The infection is treated first; a second opinion is something to get once things have settled down.

Once you have both opinions

The decision is yours, and you need enough information to make it. The steps below help you organise that information.

Find out where the difference comes from
If the two plans differ, the difference usually comes from an assumption: how much bone is left, how long the tooth will last or how long the patient can wait. Once you find the source of the difference, it also becomes clear which plan suits you.
Write your questions down and go back with them
Note down the questions that occur to you afterwards and put them to both clinics. A good clinic answers them; wherever a clinic avoids answering is where the answer lies.
Set yourself a realistic time limit
Taking a few weeks to decide is reasonable; waiting for months is not. Bone loss progresses silently, and the price of waiting is that your treatment options narrow.
Base your decision on a written plan
Whichever clinic you choose, ask for the scope in writing: how many implants, what bridgework, how many appointments, the check-ups and the guarantee. A written plan protects both you and the clinic.

Message us right away if

Your swelling is getting bigger or you have a fever. In this situation you do not wait for a second opinion. See a dentist the same day; if the swelling is spreading towards your eye or neck, go straight to A&E.
Painkillers are not controlling your pain. Pain that medicine cannot control is the clearest sign that treatment cannot be put off. It is not a situation in which to wait while you collect opinions.
The tooth is loose enough to move with your finger. At this stage most of the supporting bone may already have been lost. The assessment should not be delayed; every month you wait reduces the bone that the next treatment will sit in.
You are not being given your records. You have the right to ask for a copy of your X-ray and treatment plan. If they are not given to you, a second opinion would be based on incomplete information, so pressing for them is part of making your decision.

What a second opinion costs

A second opinion usually means the fee for a consultation and, if needed, for imaging; what really needs discussing is the cost of not getting one. The items below make up that calculation.

Consultation and imaging: If the images you already have are good enough, new imaging may not be needed. If a CBCT scan is requested, ask why; a CBCT scan taken for a clear reason makes a real difference to the quality of the decision.
The cost of delay: If the decision is delayed by a few weeks, the cost is next to nothing. When it stretches over months, bone loss progresses and the treatment options narrow; that is the cost of putting things off, not of getting a second opinion.
The cost of the wrong decision: Extracting a tooth that could have been saved, or keeping a tooth that cannot be saved for months: both are paid for in bone. This is where the real value of a second opinion lies.
A quote you can compare: A side benefit of a second opinion is a second written plan. Comparing two plans on their scope is both cheaper and safer than deciding on the strength of a single quote.

Frequently asked questions

Is getting a second opinion disrespectful to my dentist?

No, and a good dentist will not take it that way. Asking for a second look before a decision that cannot be undone is normal in every area of medicine. If your dentist reacts badly, that in itself is something to weigh up in your assessment.

Do they have to give me my X-ray if I ask for it?

Your health records belong to you, and asking for a copy is a normal request. At most clinics, sharing them digitally takes minutes. If they are not given to you, you need to insist, because otherwise the second opinion will be based on incomplete information.

Two dentists are telling me different things. Which one should I believe?

Look at the reasoning, not the answer. The more solid opinion is the one that can show you the basis for its decision on the image, explains the alternatives and the trade-offs of each, and can also tell you about an option that does not suit you. If both dentists give the same reasoning, the difference is only in their approach.

Do you charge for a second opinion?

Reviewing the images you already have is usually enough for us to make an assessment; if new imaging is needed, we tell you at the outset. If we conclude that we are not right for you, we put that in writing too: our protocol is not needed for a problem with a single tooth.

How many opinions should I get?

Two is usually enough. A third opinion makes sense if the first two are very different from each other. Going from clinic to clinic until you hear the answer you want is not making a decision but putting it off, and the price of putting it off is paid in bone.

Can I get a second opinion remotely from a clinic in another country?

A preliminary assessment can be made by sharing your X-rays and CBCT scan, and that is a useful start. But an opinion given without an examination is a preliminary assessment; a definitive plan is not drawn up without seeing your mouth. Use a remote opinion knowing its limits.

What should I do if the second opinion also says the tooth should come out?

Then the real question is no longer whether the tooth can be saved but how the gap will be dealt with. It is important to plan this before the extraction: when a gap is left, the opposing tooth in the other jaw drifts into the space, the neighbouring teeth tilt and the bone in that area resorbs.

Sources

Send your X-ray and we will tell you which option is realistic for your tooth.

Get an assessment

Next step

Send your X-ray and we will talk through the options.

Share your CBCT or panoramic X-ray. We will write back within 24 hours on which option is realistic for your tooth.

Get an assessment